Book review: Leaving ADDIE for SAM: will agile eLearning development become mainstream?


I have read the book from Michael Allen ( and Richard Sites) with a lot of interest and it is a book that I can recommend to read, it does explain the why and the how of the approach and it contains a lot of practical stuff like examples and check list that will help you get started.

I believe that an agile approach will bring a lot of benefits to e-Learning development. I wrote a couple of post on this subject in the past few years so I am delighted that a heavy weight in our learning domain supports this trend, hopefully making it more mainstream. I’m interested in agile development because we develop the easygenerator software in an agile way. It gives huge advantages over the classic ‘waterfall’ models. I believe if you translate this to e-Learning development, it will change not only the way we create e-Learning courses, but also the courses itself. Michael and Richard present us an agile alternative for ADDIE: SAM (Successive Approximation Model).

The book starts with why we need a new approach. It lists the short comings of a lot of e-Learning courses in a clear way. It is followed by an analysis of ADDIE, looking at its original form and some new manifestations. It makes interesting reading because it is not a theoretical story but they have written it from the perspective of the learners needs. Their conclusion is: ADDIE falls short, we need something else (and I agree).

In the third chapter they have a look at what ‘good’ eLearning should be, I quote: “Concise, effective learning events, whether delivered through e-Learning or not, are meaningful, memorable, and motivational. And they achieve measurable results, too.” And they explain CCAF (Context, challenge, activity, feedback). With this they set the stage for the process and introduce SAM.

There is a simple version (SAM1), for small projects”

SAM 1

And a more extended version (SAM2) for larger projects”

Sam2

I will not discuss all details (you should read the book) but what they do is take the iterative nature (short development sprints) of agile development and combine it with a prototyping approach. I like this; it will bring a lot of the advantages of agile software development to your e-Learning development. The book contains a huge amount of examples, checklists and even a complete project plan. It will help you to create learning goals and it gives examples of specific approaches (like the Savvy start and prototyping). The Savvy start is the second concept they introduce in this book. A concept that will help you to become more agile in your design process. It is clear that both authors have a few decades of combined experience in eLearning development. This enables them not only to develop an approach but explain it with very practical examples. And as you can expect from me I’m very happy with the chapter on instructional objectives, this is the way it should be done! The second part of this book is so rich, that even if you don’t want to switch to a more agile approach it is a must read. It is a goldmine of useful tips for every instructional designer.

Michael and Richard created a great foundation for a new agile approach. At the same time I think that they missed a lot of best practices and techniques that an agile approach can offer you. Daily stand ups, user stories, a back log, agile estimations, setting priorities, an agile team, demo’s to involve your clients. There is a lot more that can be used. I will write some future posts on this, trying to make the translation from best practices and techniques in agile software development to Agile e-Learning development. I will try to add another practical layer to the SAM foundation.

Ordering information Leaving ADDIE for SAM:

Books published by ASTD Press can be purchased by visiting ASTD’s website at store.astd.org or by calling 800.628.2783 or 703.683.8100:

  • Library of Congress Control Number (print edition only): 2009940017
  • PDF e-book edition ISBN: 978-1-60728-675-2
  • Print edition ISBN: 978-1-56286-711-9

And finally some links to earlier post I wrote on agile eLearning development:

  •  A post with links to other ‘agile’ eLearning posts
  • A post that I wrote for the ASTD’s big question blog on agile development
  • And my first post on agile development after I joined easygenerator

This post is part of a series I’m writing on agile eLearning development:

More post will follow over the next few weeks.

Comments

  1. George W. Leach says:

    My background is Computer Science and software development. And the first time I heard of ADDIE in a Graduate Level Instructional Design and Technology course my first impression was that it sounded like the old waterfall methodology in software design and development and that the ID field needed to follow he lead of the software design and development field.

  2. Sheila Truesdell says:

    Working for a software development company who just adopted Lean Agile last year, I can attest to the fact that our eLearning development has become more “nugget sized” and iterative out of necessity. In addition to serving our development teams better, we are serving our end users better by improving their learning experience. It’s great to know that there is a name for what we had to do to survive. It’s even better to able to point to a published process that supports and describes our methodology and how we add value. This article (and book) could not have come out at a better time!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Book review: Leaving ADDIE for SAM: will agile eLearning development become mainstream? – Chal… – This is very similar to the Rapid-ADDIE model we use. I think it is inevitable as e-learning follows software into the SaaS model where everything is perpetual beta. [...]

  2. […] Post 1: Review on Michael Allen’s book ‘Leaving ADDIE for SAM […]

  3. […] series is sparked by the book ‘Leaving ADDIE for SAM’ by Michael Allen and Richard Sites. I wrote a book review on it (and it love it). I do believe that agile software development can offer us even more very […]

  4. […] Review on Michael Allen’s book ‘Leaving ADDIE for SAM […]

  5. […] Review on Michael Allen’s book ‘Leaving ADDIE for SAM […]

  6. […] Leaving ADDIE for SAM The book ‘Leaving Addie’ for Sam by Michael Allen and Richard Sites inspired me to write these series. A must read for anyone involved in eLearning development. […]

  7. […] I did expect her to make the connection between agile and lean. I do know about agile, I wrote a whole bunch of post on it. I know a bit about lean and was curious about the connection. Instead she took us through […]

  8. […] you read this blog more often you know that I’m a fan of Michael and of agile development. (see my series of post on the topic).Michael only covered three of the 5 advantages, because he had to explain the basic […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,083 other followers

%d bloggers like this: